Top-seeded Rutgers-Newark scored a late equalizer and then was a perfect 5-for-5 in penalty kicks to advance past McDaniel and into the 2026 ECAC Men’s Soccer Tournament Championship.
McDaniel had led from the 27th minute after David O’Donnell came off the bench to score his second goal of the year. A sweeping ball into the box was batted down by Rutgers-Newark’s David Bejarano, but he was unable to get back to his feet and re-position himself before the bouncing ball was kneed into the empty net by O’Donnell.
The Green Terror had withstood a constant barrage of shots from Rutgers-Newark before the Scarlet Raiders found the tying goal, facing 14 in just the second half alone, but their defense eventually succumbed to the pressure and Rutgers-Newark found enough of a crease to get the ball past Ilan Golden.
Noah Rousson sent a great cross into the middle of the box, where a streaking Erick Cortes and the Green Terror goalkeeper, Gavin Yartymyk, were converging. Cortes got to the ball first and chipped his shot over Yartymyk’s shoulder and into the net to make it a 1-1 game.
The teams would go to extra time, and after 20 minutes with neither side scoring, the game would need to be decided by a penalty-kick shootout.
Both teams made their first two kicks, but McDaniel’s third attempt sailed over the crossbar to give Rutgers-Newark the 3-2 advantage. Later leading 4-3 in the shootout, Tristan Bastos stepped up and buried his attempt to send his Scarlet Raiders into next week’s title game.
Rutgers-Newark will play Juniata on Saturday, November 21st for the 2026 ECAC Men’s Soccer Championship.